What Would Jesus Build?
Thursday, August 20th, 2009
by James Tomlin, Architect, Certified Church Consultant, LEED-AP
For the past 8 years of my career as an architect, I have been specializing in worship facilities exclusively. I enjoy getting involved with churches who are planning to build, and I love helping them develop their properties into facilities that support and enhance their ministry in creative and innovative ways. Yet I will be the first to admit that the last thing this world needs right now is another church building. What the world needs most is fear of God and worship of Him.
So, after watching this video of an enormous expensive cathedral being built recently, I find myself compelled to comment…
On the one hand, I really appreciate what this church has accomplished. I know all too well the intense struggle to get even a metal box built for your church, let alone a Gothic Revival cathedral. On the other hand, I really do not think that an 18th-century design solution is at all appropriate in the 21st century. What was once so appropriate in the Age of Enlightenment is now anachronistic in the Age of Disenchantment. A church that replicates an 18th century design solution is offering an escape from reality, when it should instead be encouraging a holy engagement in it.
What this church has done is build yet another example of what we refer to as a cruise ship – and a very classic and elegant one at that. A cruise ship church is designed to be a destination, a heaven on earth which offers an extravagant escape from reality in all sorts of entertaining activities and diversions. On the other hand, a battleship church is designed to be a lean mean ministry machine, purposeful and functional and strategic in supporting and equipping the church to carry out its mission.
While I agree – passionately – with those who complain about the lack of beauty in contemporary church architecture, I also agree – compassionately – with those who complain about the greater needs in our culture going unmet while the Church is busy raising money for projects like this. Is there really something about this style of building which is divinely inspired for the purpose of turning our hearts and minds over to Christ in reverent submission to Him? Architecture does have the ability to transform us, but only God has the authority.
All I know is that I have had some of the most intense moments of God-worship in some of the most unlikely places and situations. God constantly surprises me by showing up in some of the most mundane profane environments. And, when I look over at my brothers and sisters in the most persecuted nations of the world, where church buildings are routinely burned down by the authorities, I see God moving and working amongst them in such spine-tingling ways it makes me jealous. They have so little materially, yet sooo much spiritually. While we have sooo much materially and by comparison so little spiritually.
And the idea that we need buildings like this to inspire our thoughts heavenward seems presumptuous. Watching the church service in this video reminded me of Gene Edwards’ description of angels attending a performance of Handel’s Messiah in a grand cathedral and asking each other “what is that awful noise?” and “why is it so dim in here?” Our attempts to create “a taste of heaven” here on earth are really nothing but a mud puddle compared to the vast unfathomable ocean where God sits on His throne.
I think Jesus would have us be beautiful people first before He would have us go to such great lengths and expense to build beautiful buildings. I do not mean beautiful people as in magazine cover material, I mean people who are beautiful because they reflect the truth and beauty and goodness of Christ. The indwelt Body is His temple now, and He is building it not with the hands but with the souls of His people.
When we become that kind of people, I believe God might then bless us with the talent and skill to once again create church buildings that have truth and beauty and goodness. And once again they will not look like anything that has ever been done before or since. Church architects should not be copying the past, but joining Christ in making new creations.




